A Farmer, a Consultant, and the USA

Occasionally, when people find out I’m American, a political discussion ensues. I certainly don’t mind talking geopolitics, and going over the complexity of the whole thing. But usually I’m asked very pointed questions, questions I’m not entirely sure hoe to answer. I’m called on to answer on behalf of the United States, and sorry, I’m not secretary of state (yet…). To be specific, there are two conversations in particular that I thought highlighted some points we tend not to think about. Firstly, the financial aide given by America to developing nations, and secondly, how our involvement in development projects may be hindering more than helping. I apologize in advance for an overwhelming lack of knowledge on these topics, but I’ll highlight these conversations, and hear out what people said.

Valentine and the farmer.

You may remember Valentine from my adventure in Altyn Arashan. This hard-as-nails manly man had a few strong opinions regarding our involvement in global politics. We both agreed that the situation is complicated, and that our history with Russia could have gone over a little more smoothly (and still could be…). The example he cited was the following:
When we give aide to foreign projects, specifically food donations, we as Americans will give a lot of money to see that cause come to fruition (we agreed this is a good thing). When that food arrives in target country, we would expect that said food programs are put into place and people are fed. Ideally, this food would be donated, free of charge, to those in need. We were in agreement that many programs do this. However, from his experience on the distribution side of things in a past life, he stated that most programs will SELL that food at a highly discounted price. This gives slight profit margins (maybe not even profit, perhaps just covering some operating costs) to the program, and gives buyers a better deal. Now here’s where Valentine gets aggravated. Think of the farmer whose small crop yield took quite a lot of labor, who then brings it to market (often great distances at a cost to himself). He is selling at $10…while the US food program is selling at $5. You can see where an issue starts to arise. The farmer sells no product, and now has less to go into his crop yield later on. When this farmer gets bought out and cannot afford to sell anymore, a monopoly arises with the food aide program…who then start to sell at $10..$15. You can see where his frustration came from.

Shaktybek and a certain consulting company.

I met Shaktybek while in Karakol, and he was an absolute pleasure to get to know. His background is in telecommunications, and for years was involved in implementing the telecommunications infrastructure here in Kyrgyzstan, and eventually sat under the vice minister of the country. When politics became complicated (the most recent revolution, as it were), it was expected that Shaktybek would start taking bribes for himself and those above him (among other things), as the proletariat could become stronger. He couldn’t do it, and resigned his position. He then entered international consulting, living in London, Switzerland, and the US for some time. He did this in the telecommunications field at first, and then found himself working on a development project at home in Kyrgyzstan. It was through this project that he transitioned into becoming heavily involved in Kyrgyz development projects. Though we talked for hours about many issues, this one frustrated him the most:
He was incredibly excited when a project he was working on was approved for aide from the USA. He thought to himself “ah, the United States, now we will have the help we need”. We donated a sum of money, and instead of sending consultants directly (as he was used to doing in his prior experience), the US hired an outside consulting company, one with quite a famous international name. He was unused to the idea of a third party, but was still excited because of the name of this company. They sent somebody to Karakol to head up the project, and to meet with Shaktybek, the local point man. As he began talking with this consultant, he learned that they had almost zero experience whatsoever. Not only regarding the project they were accomplishing (something about tourism and a cheese factory), but almost no experience….at all. He continued to give two additional examples of almost the same thing happening; You can imagine how disheartened he was to learn that with the USA at the helm, hiring a well known consulting company, the nation of Kyrgyzstan took a back seat.
It was this last though that struck me. Sure, every international consultant may start somewhere with no experience, but you wouldn’t expect it from such a large company. However, it was this idea that Shaktybek felt that his country is not taken seriously as a nation to be invested in. He explained to me their vast natural resources (which, recently, a mining contract was turned down by the USA…), their desire for democracy and education, and to be considered globally minded. He passively mentioned that most global councils have yet to add the Kyrgyz language to their texts.
So what am I trying to get at here? I know far too little about the details of food programs, government aide, geopolitics or consulting, to state whether things are true, how complex they are (and I’m sure they are very complex), and what goes on in the background. But that’s not my point.
My point is that people see what we do in a very different light than what we think. We watch a moving film on Sunday, and pour our money into companies, programs, and websites. A few people even work abroad, and yet sometimes, it’s not being done in the right way. The perspective of what we do is undermined, and perhaps with due cause to think so.
So like…do I have a solution for the entire development project side of the US government? Haha…no. But I think it’s good to have these conversations and to think about things. Valentine and I applauded US companies that stimulate local economies by doing things such as digging wells, irrigation systems, giving farming tools, seeds, and business micro-loans. Shaktybek and I were happy to talk about the success of many projects done by various US companies who found the right people for the job to develop a clear strategy, set up the right people, and follow through with the plan. There were still positive sides to these conversations.
And I think this matters. I think it matters how people view us. I think it’s a matter of fact that our actions, as a nation, have weight (amongst every other nation!). We have a reputation of being able to help, and we should guard that reputation by appropriate actions to see that help go through.
I guess the take home is that if you want to give money to a program, give time in an office, or even go abroad and work, to do your research and ask a lot of questions as to implementation. More than that though, don’t forget that we’re living in a truly global time, and that each place has something to bring to the table. Nobody deserves a back seat, or to be forgotten or thought lesser of.
A final note- I’m sure many of those reading have positive examples, and I’m glad of that. A few of you will want to do a fact-check rant, I’m not looking for an argument. I’m just hoping to bring to light some interesting conversations I had with real people on the ground, highlighting some areas to work on. I hope this all stimulates and inspires you to follow through and be excellent in whatever you’re doing. Thanks for reading!
-BK

Central Asia: Karakol, The worst road, and a guy named “Bob”.

High up in the mountains outside of Karakol, Kyrgyzstan, via a nearly inaccessible road, I had reached Altyn Arashan. Here I sat, completely naked, and completely silent, in a natural hot spring with a man whose name had an impossible combination of “v”s and “ch”s, whom we agreed to call “Bob”. Occasionally we hit the pause button and realize we are in a unique moment in time, and this was no exception. But before I come back to this, this story starts back in Bishkek a couple days ago.
Having received 2 of 3 visas in Bishkek, and the third awaiting my call the following Monday morning, I had time to get out of Bishkek for a few days, and there was no better place than Karakol. This sleepy little town is renowned for its outdoor scene, and tends to have a “must not miss” reputation around the traveler’s hub. It’s 6.5 hours from Bishkek to Karakol, and along the way it was nice to see some mountain scenery, fresh air, and the stunning lake Issyk-Köl (I posted some pics already!). Once I got there I walked to my hostel, a very clean and spacious property with an owner who speaks near perfect English (so nice!).
The next day I headed to Jetti-Ogüz. A combination of mashrukta (a sort of public bus system- think a dodge sprinter packed wth people getting on and off, paying about 50 cents a ride), hitch hiking, and taxi got me to the small outpost in the mountains south of Jetti-Ogüz proper. About and hour worth of traveling outside Karakol. Though the hiking trails weren’t marked, and I was fairly confused where to go, I simply hiked up the nearby hill as far as I could and was rewarded with some pretty incredible views of mountain peaks, horses at pasture, and the famed “seven bulls” sandstone formations looming over the valley. I’d say it was worth the wiggling to get here.
I relaxed back at the hostel, and had some very in-depth discussions with our hostel owner about development projects in Kyrgyzstan, as well as the developing world at large. He has a long history working as an international consultant in his past life, and has transitioned into humanitarian work here at home, and is incredibly involved with excellent perspective and ideas. I hope to make a separate post talking about his thoughts, as well as some others conversations I’ve had along these same lines. But back to our story- he suggested some other things I should do: including the Sunday morning animal market (largest in central Asia, and Altyn Arashan, THE must not miss destination).
Up at 6:30 am, the animal market was a real hoot. It’s just what it sound like- a massive bazaar vibe, all centre around selling animals. Lots of yelling, laughing, animal noises, and stall-food (omgyessss). It was a lot of fun for me to roam around, and was requested to take pictures of people and their animals almost every 5 minutes. Every photographers dream! Then came some decisions about Altyn Arashan; you see, it’s about an 8 hour hike there, followed by sleeping in the valley, then about 4-5 hours hike back. Not for the faint of heart, or those with 4 very painful, irritating blisters on their feet (hey, that’s me). But, I figured, I probably shouldn’t miss this, and I’d have to deal with the pain anyway. So I took the mashrukta to the trailhead, and started walking.
About 30 minutes into the hike, I heard the sound of an engine…to be specific…the engine of an old, war-hardedend russian van-tank (at which point a van turns into an indestructible off-road vehicle, I’m not sure, but this piece of machinery was flirting the line). I waved them down, and as my luck would have it, it was the owner of Yak tours (one of the hostels in the valley) and his driver coming back from a supply run. This is incredibly rare, and I was pretty excited to hop on in. And we started our ascent.

Valentine and the van-tank
I can’t properly describe the condition of this “road”. I think hiking it by foot would be difficult, and never in my most daring assumptions would I call it a road meant to be traversed by vehicles. 50% mud, 80% boulder, and 100% fury (here’s to you Furiosa), this is by far the worst piece of socially acceptable vehicle routes I’ve ever encountered. My respect for the vehicle and it’s driver are as high as the risk of being crushed by falling rocks- very high.
After about an hour and a half of rock-climbing-with-a-van, we crested the valley of Altyn-arashan, a steep, alpine valley with some serious mountain peaks in the distance. It was, to say the least, absolutely beautiful. Having ascended with these guys, I essentially signed up to stay with them, which is fine. Their “hostel” was a very simple adirondak-esque cabin, with few accouterments, and which hadn’t been cleaned in perhaps…ever. Valentine (pronounced “teen”, not “tine”) whipped up some vegetable stew, and we shared a lunch together.
It was after this lunch that he suggested I check out the hot springs. So the van-tank driver and I walked over to the hot spring, which consisted of a shed with an actually really well developed little pool feel to it. I figured I’d introduce myself to the monster-truck driver, and we settled on “Bob”. Then Bob stripped naked and got in. I had a decision to make here. Would I go ahead and do the I’ll-stay-in-my-short-b/c-im-obvioulsy-uncomfortable….or…just cultural immersion. I chose the latter. And that brings us around to the the start of this story. Don’t you worry, Valentine joined about 10 minutes later.

Bob the van-tank driver and hot spring tour guide

Hot spring
The overnight was bone chilling, but luckily I had a rock hard bed to sleep on and a thin blanket to remind me that I love my down-jacket. Overnight, a hunter apparently dropped off some wild boar, which we ate as a stew in the morning, Valentine, Bob and I. The three amigos, knowing so much more about each other than a mere 12 hours ago. They had to run back to town for more supplies, so I was lucky again to hitch another spine-shattering ride down. All in all, very glad that I was luckily enough to catch the chance to see the valley, and now have a story I won’t be forgetting soon.

The road to Altyn Arashan

Altyn Arashan and the van-tank
Until next time, thanks for reading!
-BK

Bishkek and the Visa Trail

I’ve spent about 1 week in the capital city of Bishkek. A sleepy city with soviet-esque architecture, but an entirely independent attitude and vibe, this is generally a haven for travelers to pick up visas that are more difficult to obtain elsewhere. That being said, there is no shortage of visa-difficulty in this down. The following note will focus on my visa-obtaining adventures, and I’ll make another post talking about my impressions of Bishkek itself. But we left off in Almaty, so let’s wind it back a bit, and catch everybody up to what I’ve been doing.
Leaving Almaty was pretty easy; I took public bus to the regional bus station, where I was expecting to find transport to the border, with the need to do the same once in Kyrgyzstan. However, was able to find a mini-bus with service straight through to Bishkek. It was only 1300 tengi (about 4 dollars). The road was in pristine condition, and it was a beautiful day! We scooted along to the border, hopped off of our mini-bus and went through the appropriate Kazakh border procedures. No issues (make sure to have your departure card you received coming in- obviously-although one traveler got stuck in the queue next to me). Then we walked on foot into Kyrgyzstan (87 for me), whereI very anticlimactically received a stamp and I was in! The bus was waiting not he other side, and off we went to downtown Bishkek. Took about 4.5 hours all in all.
Once in Bishkek I took a taxi to my hostel (Interpose Hostel on Toktugal St.). It was pretty empty, but run by a fleet of college age girls, who are pretty helpful making any phone calls you need around town (cough embassies cough). I hit the hay (alone in a 6 bed dorm...), and began my visa adventure the next morning.
Understand: What is a visa you ask? Essentially a very-official permission slip to enter another country. Depending on your country’s relations with target country, you amy or may not need one, and if you do, the difficulty of obtaining one will vary. The standard procedure is send an application, passport, and supporting documents to that nation’s embassy in XX country, and get your visa. Bishkek has al of the embassies of the neighboring countries, with the additional advantage of visa issuance being fast and cheap. Hence, me being in Bishkek to get some visas.
Day 1: So I call the Uzbekistan Embassy in the morning. She gives me an appointment..for tomorrow. Alrighty then, I guess that’s that. So I decided to be all super-efficient and said, hey, lemme get my visa for Tajikistan today while I wait. So I headed over to the Tajik embassy (it’s in a very odd part of town, but a good taxi driver- like anybody from Jogul taxi company) will use their smartphone to find it). It was the easiest visa I’ve ever received. I paid $75 USD for a double entry visa, plus 100 som (about $1.46) for the GBAO permit (restricted area permit to visit the Pamir mountains). I waited two hours (they had a lunch break), and I had it. NICE! While I waited, I decided to get even mor efficient and called the embassy of Afghanistan in Bishkek. I discussed with he consular’s secretary the process for obtaining a visa for US citizen. He explained that it was relatively easy, given my meeting with them go well. I scheduled this meeting for the next day at 2pm. I went back to my hostel and spent the rest of the day talking with a long-term inhabitant “”Tony””, an expat teaching at the American University of Central Asia.
Day 2: I head to the Uzbek embassy for my 10am appt. Now, the lady at the embassy is infamous amongst travel blogs, books, and word of mouth as being, lets say, difficult. I was the first to be called upon my the wicked witch from the west, and I figured my actions were gonna affect everybody behind me. I played it smooth. Approaching the iron bars of her jail cell (or was I in the cell?), I first asked how her day was going. This proved to be what we call “a good move”. She shifted in her seat, smiled, and said she’s doing OK. Alright, going well. I handed in my paperwork, and had to request to keep my passport while they prices (fingers crossed), which surprisingly, wasn’t an issue at all. WHEW. I spent some time walking around the central part of the city and “hanging out”, then headed over to the Afghan embassy.
IT went like this: Knock, wait a long time. Then the Consular’s secretary comes down to interview you. There were general questions such as “why are you in Bishkek”, “what do you do”, etc. Depending on this interview (and apparently if he likes you?), they will decided to issue you the visa or not. After a quick compliment on his rings, I had a grand old time chatting with the secretary. He left to talk with the Consular, and returned saying “we will issue you the visa. Here is the application, fill it out and bring it back tomorrow at 9:30”. And that was that. I had to go to the Bank of Pakistan to pay the visa fee (?), and after that, meandered around town and back to the hostel.
Day 3 in Bishkek. I flutter my eyes awake, happy about my Tajik visa, and proud of the progress with Afghanistan. I headed over to the embassy, and handed the application to the secretary. The visa fee for US citizens is a whopping $160 for 9 day processing, or $200 for 24 hour processing. I chose the latter (and introduced myself to financial serfdom). I was instructed to pick it up tomorrow at noon.
Day 4: Since my visa is being processed sans passport with the Uzbek embassy, I was planning on heading to the hills after I picked it up from the Afghan embassy. SO I packed my things and headed to the embassy. Lo and behold, the visa was issued, no issues at all. Single entry, 30 days. Of note, the particular town I plan to head to is the town the secretary is from, and the hotel I chose is about 100m from his house. He was very excited about this, and it was encouraging to hear how excited he was that I was visiting such a nice place. He also gave me his personal cell phone and email, and the contact info of his brother, who lives there currently, should any issues arise.
I will call the Uzbek embassy Monday (as instructed), when I assume I will be told to “come tomorrow”. A lot of “tomorrow’s”...but that’s a lot better than “no”, or several weeks of processing elsewhere. No problem!
It should be stated that I never travel without doing an incredible amount of research. My travel strategy is to be flexible, without planning too far ahead, but knowing all of the options. When I arrive to a place, I know what is available, how longs it takes to get to different towns, etc, and I make my choices as I go along. Afghanistan is a well-researched destination, with careful phone calls made to the appropriate people.
And so I was able to head to the hills and beauty of Lake Issyk-Köl. I will post about my adventures/relaxation here soon, after my Bishkek piece. I hope some of the information above regarding visas comes as a great help to any travelers planning similar routes. Stay posted!
-BK